In his preface to Spiritual Depression, Geoffrey Thomas relays the brief account of a young woman who visited Dr. Lloyd-Jones with concern for the church. The woman in question was involved in a long evangelistic campaign in London. The campaign, sponsored by an American evangelist, was not supported by Lloyd-Jones. Being attracted to the campaign and its methods, the young woman made two visits to Lloyd-Jones with two critiques. She claimed (a) that the gospel was not preached at Westminster Chapel, and (b) the people of the church lacked love for one another. Here’s how she remembers the second conversation, which took place in a dark period of her spiritual life:
Woman: “We don’t love one another in this church.”
Lloyd-Jones (tenderly): “Don’t say that. It’s the devil that makes you say that.”
A couple questions come immediately to mind for me.
1. How would one individual in a church be able to pronounce that the entire church is without love?
How could any one person have data enough to conclude this? And if the conclusion were accurate, we’d have to stop using the term “church” to describe that group of people. For whatever we might call that body of people, we could not call it a “church” since love is a distinguishing mark of the church (John 13:34-35; 1 John 3:14-15).
The woman sounds humble. After all, she says, “We don’t love one another.” She seems to put herself in the crowd of calloused hearts. But, in fact, this is little more than a dark pride. By “we,” we’re better off understanding her to say “everyone else is like me. If there is a defect in my love, then surely there must be a defect in everyone else’s.” Or, she really stands accusing others and “we” becomes the polite disguise for her charge. So “we” really becomes a finger-pointing “you all.” Ever noticed the tendency to spread our own sins and faults onto others with words like “we” and “us.” We have no empirical data and no ability to know the state of anyone’s soul–much less everyone’s. But with the sheep’s clothing of “we” and “us,” the lurking wolf of our own depravity gobbles everyone else up in our sin or accusation.
How often are we tempted to say “we” when what we really mean is “I” or “You”? I have this sin problem. Or, I think all you have this sin problem. But “I” feels too damaging to our self-image, and “you” seems to confrontational. Pride and fear of man usually opts for plural first person pronouns. That’s the best camouflage.
Note: Stop saying “we” when what I really mean is “I” or “you” or I can’t know the real state of “we.”
2. As a pastor, would I tenderly but firmly tell the person “the devil makes you say that”?
That’s a bold response from Lloyd-Jones. I admire it. I admire it because the woman’s own testimony is that he was tender in saying it. I also admire it because he is certainly correct. What good is there in being tender if you’re not also truthful?
Lloyd-Jones reminds us that we ought to see and study God’s love among our churches. The Spirit pours the love of God in our heart. The Son demonstrates the love of God in His cross. The Father shows His love by sending the Son into the world to save sinners. The Christian participates in the fellowship of love between the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit. God is love. We are loved.
If we cannot see love among the people of God, either these are not the people of God or the god of this world has blinded us to the love of God at work among us. I am persuaded that most often it is the second cause–Satan’s blinding influence. The enemy does not want us to see the love of God moving, renewing, strengthening, and sustaining the people of God. He does not want us to know and rely upon the love God has for us, or to share that love with one another. He tempts us to say untrue and unbelieving things. Only Satan would prompt such a judgment as “We don’t love one another in this church.” This, of course, means that sometimes we may speak as Satan’s dupes rather than as ambassadors of Christ. Terrible shame.
If we believe our churches are made up of genuine born-again believers, we have every reason to believe our church family loves. Our love will be imperfect. There may be soft spots in it and some may slip through the cracks of our love. We may be aware of deficiencies of various kinds. But all the while, there surges and swells in the hearts of every Christian in our church an other worldly affection, a divine charity, an ineffable benevolence.
Because Christ lives in us, our love is so certain that statements to the contrary come only from the pits of hell. Don’t speak for Satan. Speak for Jesus.
Is your church family really loveless? No, it’s not. It’s full of God’s love. Go discover, share, and nurture God’s love among God’s people.